I would rule yes. You’ve removed the verbal component of Suggestion so you can cast it completely silently and it never says you specifically have to say your suggestion out loud so giving it to them telepathically works.
How does subtle spell work 5e?
Subtle Spell can remove the somatic and verbal components of a spell. That feature has no effect on any other aspect of a spell. For example, charm person says the target knows you charmed them. Subtle Spell has no effect on that statement.
What is the point of subtle spell?
The purpose of Subtle Spell is not to remove or affect conditions such as restrained or grappled; it’s to make it impossible to detect that you are casting the spell (if it only has verbal/somatic components) until you have already finished casting it.
How does the suggestion spell work?
You suggest a course of activity (limited to a sentence or two) and magically Influence a creature you can see within range that can hear and understand you. Creatures that can’t be Charmed are immune to this Effect. The suggestion must be worded in such a manner as to make the course of action sound reasonable.
Can you counterspell suggestion?
4 Answers. Following RAW, there a number of ways to counter Suggestion: Counterspell (PHB 228 – your bard has the best chance at this) Bard’s Countercharm (PHB 54 – if you know it’s coming, this works.
Does subtle spell work in silence?
You might not even need Subtle Metamagic As long as you are outside the Silence when you cast the spell, but the object itself is inside, the Silence spell will absorb the loud noise. Knock has a 60ft range, so it should be perfectly doable to stand outside the Silence field and cast the spell into it.
Can you subtle spell while paralyzed?
No, you cannot cast.
Is suggestion a good spell?
The Suggestion spell has been used in combat probably an incalculable amount of times by various players the world over. It can totally work the way you suggest, though usually it’s up to the DM to sort out how the wording of the suggestion affects the outcome. Biggest key is the course of action sounding reasonable.
Does suggestion Count as charm?
which has been interpreted to mean that the spell is a form of charm spell. The spell and the suggestion spell are fairly classic charms in the wider concept, as they magically coerce the target(s) to perform actions that they likely wouldn’t perform otherwise.
Can you dispel Magic suggestion?
Calm Emotions suppresses charm effects. Counterspell can stop it before it starts. Dispel Evil and Good can break charm effects, but only works against celestials, elementals, fey, fiends, and undead. Dispel Magic is always a good option for undoing spell effects.
What can you do with a subtle spell?
With subtle spell you can cast it right in front of them any they have no idea. Minor illusion a call for help, Friends the guard, issue a Suggestion to let you go, or just make a hypnotic pattern and walk away.
What do you need to know about the suggestion spell?
Jeremy Crawford has stated that the Suggestion spell requires the chanting of “mystic words” in addition to the spoken suggestion. Here are what I see as the best practices for this scenario. If you want to take an action, but don’t want players to know you’re taking an action, you should make a stealth check.
Do you need to touch the components of a spell?
If it has a material component, you need to be touching your focus or the component, but if you have a staff as your arcane focus and it’s in your hand, you are fine there. A lot of components can also be handled secretly.
Can a subtle spell let you remain in hiding?
And if you want to argue that an attack spell without verbal or somatic components (whether cast with Subtle Spell or not) should let you remain in hiding, why doesn’t firing a bow, or a slingshot, then?
